<> In
Brief:
Men’s
Health Lags
Behind Women’s
in Social Report
Men
are lagging behind women in five of the six health
indicators compiled for the government’s 2004 Social Report. The annual
Social
Report attempts to measure the social wellbeing of a Society with a
wider range
of indicators than just economic.
There
is a nearly five year gap in life expectancy between
males and females in New Zealand according to the latest available
figures
(2000-02). A New Zealand male cannot expect to reach retirement age
(65)
without a disability that will require assistance by another person or
a
complex device: this “independent life expectancy” is 64.8 years for
men and
67.5 for women. Overall the rate of disability has risen slightly for
men
between 1996 and 2001 to 10.2% and fallen for women to 9.3%
Men
also lead the suicide statistics, with 77% of all
suicides being males. Internationally New Zealand is different than
most other
countries as here it is younger men (up
to 35) who kill themselves, whereas elsewhere men over 65 are most at
risk.
Within the OECD New Zealand has the worst male youth suicide rate.
The
only health indicator where men fared better than women
is obesity, although the latest figures in the Social Report were from
1997.
18% of adult non-Maori women were considered obese (28% for Maori), but
only
13% of non-Maori males (27% for Maori).
Men
were also lagging behind women in some other key
indicators, such as satisfaction with work/life balance (women overall
happier)
and participation in tertiary education. Men are more than twice as
likely than
women to get injured during work.
Maori
were also doing significantly worse than non-Maori in
all of the health indicators in the Social Report. A Maori male’s
independent life expectancy is a mere 58 years. In
most health indicators the gap between males and females is bigger for
non-Maori than for Maori.
“Lads
Need
Whole Person Approach” - Report
A
research review about successful
approaches for working with young males issued by the Ministry of Youth
Development calls for a strength-based approach to youth work centred
around
‘anchoring points’.
“Young
men need as many ‘anchoring
points’ - contact with competent, caring and prosocial adults—as
possible.” The
review also found that “the more intense a programme is, and the longer
it goes
for, the more effective it is likely to be.”
The
report is critical of
‘educational’ programmes for young men, performed in a group setting
and
focusing on only one ‘problem’.
“A
‘whole person’ approach works
better than a problem focus. Even when addressing specific areas of
risk,
programmes will be more effective if they engage with young men’s other
needs
as well.” says the report.
Youth
Development Minister John
Tamihere had announced in August this year that young males will be one
of the
government’s top social priorities. He said he was ‘sick and tired’
that young
men are being blamed for all and everything that goes wrong.
|